There is too much made of these situations. Here are the options.
1) Let the guy sit out, fine him, he doesn't play he doesn't get paid. No player is this stupid...we'll...nevermind.
2) Rip up contract but give him what is fair. That is, fair market value. Since he is NOT a free agent he is not on the open market so his market value is MUCH lower that if he was a free agent (no one else can bid on him but the Titans so his value is what THEY say it is). So yes, Bud Adams should not be a jerk. Go ahead and give him a raise this year only but an owner is an IDIOT if he writes him a new contract with extended years "right now" because he is not worth that "right now."
Once he lives out the contract, let the chips fall where they may.
3) Be foolish and give him top money now, he gets hurt, production drops from taking too many hits, player wins, owner loses.
Option #2 is most logical but Johnson needs to be realistic to his own situation. If an owner can't renegotiate a contract for an overpaid player (many more of these) then a player should not be able to renegotiate their contract as an "underpaid" player.
Edited by SH (08/10/11 05:35 PM)